No, definitely not. The point of section 230 is to give websites the power to moderate themselves without being open to liability. IIRC previously, you had to choose between 0 moderation and no liability or moderation and liability, leading websites to either go for complete anarchy or extremely aggressive censorship.

Under most laws maybe, but many subscription models are unethical to begin with. In this case, 2 wrongs DO make a right. A right to pirate!